Issue #1637
closed
Pulp Admin returns 0 even when there are errors
Status:
CLOSED - DUPLICATE
Description
It is possible to create and sync a docker repository with the following commands:
pulp-admin docker repo create \
--feed ${feed} \
--repo-id ${repo_id} \
--upstream-name ${upstream_name}
pulp-admin docker repo sync --repo-id ${repo_id}
The second command returns a status code of 0 regardless of whether the sync succeeds.
This is a general problem with pulp-admin - most error scenarios return 0 unfortunately.
Mmhmm. I remember hearing some chatter among the devs mentioning that fact.
I'll likely continue filing bugs like this. Doing so lets me provide a concrete reason for skipping certain tests.
Ichimonji10 wrote:
Mmhmm. I remember hearing some chatter among the devs mentioning that fact.
I'll likely continue filing bugs like this. Doing so lets me provide a concrete reason for skipping certain tests.
Would be helpful if you will make those issues as 'related'
ipanova@redhat.com wrote:
Ichimonji10 wrote:
Mmhmm. I remember hearing some chatter among the devs mentioning that fact.
I'll likely continue filing bugs like this. Doing so lets me provide a concrete reason for skipping certain tests.
Would be helpful if you will make those issues as 'related'
If anyone can point me toward the more general bug listing for this issue I'd love to weigh in - I need pulp-admin to be more predictable with exit codes so that I can count on it for use in a smaller single-Pulp-server infra that can't easily make use of Pulp event emailing.
Would be helpful if you will make those issues as 'related'
Sure. I'll make an effort to remember to do this. Thanks for the heads up.
- Subject changed from Pulp Admin returns 0 even when docker sync fails to Pulp Admin returns 0 even when there are errors
- Severity changed from 2. Medium to 3. High
- Triaged changed from No to Yes
- Status changed from NEW to CLOSED - DUPLICATE
This was already filed so the triage team decided to track it through the original issue #427. Closing as DUPLICATE.
pulp-smash should track the resolution using #427.
- Is duplicate of Issue #427: Return code of the operation called by pulp-admin should be propagated to pulp-admin added
Also available in: Atom
PDF
.